No delta report from earlier versions and no details on object model.

Missing difference report and details on the object model

The difference report is unneeded.

Use of names is inconsistent – capitalization, spelling, and inclusion of the full name – i.e. including the word “Profile”.

Names are inconsistent

Use of names is inconsistent – capitalization, spelling, and inclusion of the full name – i.e. including the word “Profile”.

Missing the Model and serializations chapter

Missing the Model and serialization section

In the comments on the RFC from the AB there was a request for more information on the serializations and model.

Editorial issues with tense of names and related definitions

word tense and definition clean up

Editorial issues with tense of names and related definitions

Replace File clause with fileKind clause

File clause needs to be more flexible

Replace File clause with fileKind clause.

Missing the trademark compliance section

Missing trademark compliance section

Missing the trademark compliance section

Terms and definitions section missing

Missing Section

Terms and definitions section missing

URL links in the body should be footnotes

Need to move most URLs into footnotes for readability

URL links in the body should be footnotes to de-clutter the text.

Improved summary, descriptions, definitions, and example content, including changes from id to spdxID, update simple license info, and the elaboration of AI profile components, needs to be added from the Linux Foundation work on these clauses.

Information in summaries, descriptions, and examples can be improved

Room to improve summary, definition, and example content, including changes from id to spdxID, update simple license info, and the elaboration of AI profile components, needs to be added from the Linux Foundation work on these clauses.

element and rootElement in Bom are optional for all of the profiles except the Lite profile but currently it is a mandatory field. Need to change minCount on element and rootElement.

Bom minCount

element and rootElement in Bom are optional for all of the profiles except the Lite profile but currently it is a mandatory field. Need to change minCount on element and rootElement.

Media Type needs to be extended to include Property and better explained

Media Type needs additional information and explaination

Media Type needs to be extended to include Property and better explained

There were two Lite Profile Annexes - one on using the Lite Profile and one on what conformance meant. The using the Lite Profile was accidentally inserted instead of the conformance one.

Wrong Lite Profile Annex included

Have wrong annex on Lite profile.

The Extension Profile Class is missing appropriate Properties

Need properties defined for the Extensioin Profile Class

The Extension Profile Class is missing appropriate Properties.

The Software Profile Class is missing an identifier for content.

Content identifier details missing

The Software Profile Class is missing an identifier for content.

Need to rename Annexes due to insertion of two new ones.

Change annex letters

Need to rename Annexes due to insertion of two new ones.

The Package URL specification is not in a referable form

Add details of Package URL specifics

The Package URL specification is not in a referable form.

9.1.2 Package needs a source information property

Missing property in Package

9.1.2 Package needs a source information property

The purpose and utility of the SPDX Lite profile is not apparent and hard to understand what compliance to it will mean to existing users of the current version of that part of SPDX in the automotive and healthcare fields.

Clarify SPDX Lite purpose, utility, and compliane definition

The purpose and utility of the SPDX Lite profile is not apparent and hard to understand what compliance to it will mean to existing users of the current version of that part of SPDX in the automotive and healthcare fields.

OMG (Mike Bennett) and Linux Foundation (Steve Winslow and Mike Dolan) requested changes to the proposed materials changed in Ballot 1 first issue.

Revise legal clauses to capture agreement of OMG and LF teams

OMG (Mike Bennett) and Linux Foundation (Steve Winslow and Mike Dolan) requested changes to the proposed materials changed in Ballot 1 first issue.

Missing profile conformance materials for Licensing, Dataset, AI, and Lite profiles.

Additonal profile conformance details needed for Licensing, Dataset, AI, and Lite profiles

Missing profile conformance materials for Licensing, Dataset, AI, and Lite profiles.

The Linux Foundation and OMG have different ways of covering the legal issues.

Replace the legal prose with the Linux Foundation approach of 2 standard licenses

Replace the legal prose with the Linux Foundation approach of 2 standard licenses - Community Specification License 1.0 and Creative Commons Attribution License 3.0 Unported.

Need to support OMG and Linux Foundation use of the same document with different cover pages but only one OMG specific page.

Move the “OMG’s Issue Reporting Procedure” from page iv to the preface page

Move the “OMG’s Issue Reporting Procedure” from page iv to the preface page

The Linux Foundation document had to move to 3.0.1 and OMG version needs to be consistent.

change version from 3.0 to 3.0.1

The Linux Foundation document had to move to 3.0.1 and OMG version needs to be consistent.

Need to move References clauses to section 2 and merge Annex C: References.

consolidate references

Need to move References clauses to section 2 and merge Annex C: References.

Need to move the History, Motivation and Rationale clauses to a new non-normative Annex.

move History section to new Annex

Need to move the History, Motivation and Rationale clauses to a new non-normative Annex.

Linux Foundation documents put all Figures in an Annex.

Figures to Annex

Linux Foundation documents put all Figures in an Annex.

Systematically revise the Profile Classes to be named “Classes” , include super class information, and remove references to the figures that were moved to the annexes.

Add super class derived properties, remove profile names from classes and references to relocated figures.

Systematically revise the Profile Classes to be named “Classes” , include super class information, and remove references to the figures that were moved to the annexes.

The informative material in the History, Motivation and Rational is only from an OMG perspective and annex needs to change reference letter.

Rename History, Motivation and Rational Annex

The informative material in the History, Motivation and Rational doesn’t belong in the middle of the body of the document and is only from an OMG perspective.

Need to move Terms and Definitions clauses to section 3

Slim down the Terms and Definitions

The resolution in ballot 1 was accidentally deferred but a second issue rewrote the Terms and Definitions making this issue unneeded.

Need to rename annexes G and H as H and I.

Added additional annexes so need to rename later ones

Need to renumber annexes G and H as H and I.

Need to move Symbols clauses to section 4

Insert Symbols chapter

Need to move Symbols clauses to section 4 and mark as resolved - mistakenly marked as deferred in ballot 1

title has an unnecessary “,”.

title has an unnecessary “,”.

title has an unnecessary “,”.

Need to change the Scope section to the one approved by the Linux Foundation Steering Committee.

change the Scope section to the one approved

Need to change the Scope section to the one approved by the Linux Foundation Steering Committee.

Linux Foundation document has conformance clause not in the OMG document that needs to be added and need to renumber.

merge conformance clauses.

Linux Foundation document has conformance clause not in the OMG document that needs to be added and need to renumber.

Need to replace the Terms section, which is SPDX 2.3 specific, with materials appropriate for SPDX 3.0.

Terms section out of date

Need to replace the Terms section with non-SPDX 2.3 materials appropriate for SPDX 3.0.

Need to add additional details on the inherited properties for many of the specification classes that can be extracted from the schema and described explicitly in the specification and remove profile names from class names.

Super class details not in spec

Need to add additional details on the inherited properties for many of the specification classes that can be extracted from the schema and described explicitly in the specification and remove profile names from class names.

The Scope section covers more than scoping the document.

The Scope section covers more than scoping the document.

The Scope section covers more than scoping the document.