monitored change condition' should be owned by 'Change Condition Step'
Error in the superset of 'owned behavioral connection'
Missing Comment on Terminate
Missing notation for the 'End' Behavioral Change
The association end name "specified happening condition" for the association between Change and Change Condition must be replaced by "specified change condition".
Wrong SuperType for EmbeddedProcess
ownedInteraction should belong to Interactive Processing Behavior
Statement should be a Packageable Element
Generalization should be in Infrastructure, not CommonAbstraction
BPDM and BPMN are shortly going to merge in the next BPMN2 RFC.
In order to ensure continuity between these various RFC, BPDM should use “bpmn” as its XML Namespace.
Typed Part' should be a sub-type of 'Property' instead of 'MultiplicityElement'
There is no way to have conditions on Facts
Cancel shouldn't be in the 'Happening and Change' library
In the BPDM Beta 1 document dtc/07-07-01, in Section 6.3.2.6, page 35, the document reads
The default succession is represented by a default Marker that MUST be a backslash near the beginning of the line representing the Succession.
However, the diagram accompanying the statement shows a FORWARD slash. twice, in fact.
The Processing Behavior Package and Simple Interaction Package have a circular dependency
Property should not be navigable
From Sylvain:
p 46 Parallel Join : in the sentence « Parallel Join is a Course Control Part Indication that the parts (in the sense of individuals) following it happen after the parts preceding them »
Is the word « individuals » really appropriated ? We are positioning M0 elements (individuals) in perspective of M1 elements (Course Control Part) which have no M0 enactment...
ð Antoine
The parts mentioned in the description are the “following” parts (successor parts) of the course control part. These successors are usually a “typed course part” that represents.
We could do two things to clarify the sentence:
1. Verify that the term (individual) is explicity used other the specification as referencing M0 elements
2. Change the sentence to mention “typed course part”
« Parallel Join is a Course Control Part Indication that the typed course parts (in the sense of individuals) following it happen after the typed course parts preceding them »
There is a need to have ends that are logical failure
BPMN Universal Happening should use sub-properties
Useless ownership association between Behavioral Step Group and Processing Behavior
BPDM 1.1 has added some new shapes to the initial BPDM 1.0 specification.
BPDM should provide metamodel supports for these new shapes.
Missing notation for the 'Start' Behavioral Change
Time Change should not be abstract
From Sylvain:
p 47 Succession : in the sentence “ A Succession indicates that that one Course Part ‘follows’ another in time ”
Is this really true ? After all if we have:
Task A -à Task B
With an immediate succession between Task A and Task B, then Task A and B will be enacted at the same time, and Task A might actually last longer than Task B effectively contradicting the above statement since an ‘Immediate Succession’ is a kind of ‘Succession’.
ð Antoine
“Follows” include the fact that it could start at the same time. It says nothing about the duration (or the end) of task A versus task B
I think Conrad had a better explanation in the discussion he had with Steve White.
Conrad, could you please help clarify the sentence.
involving interaction-involved interactive part' should be a derived union
CommonAbstractions' should be an independant Package
Typo error in 'conditionning behavioral step'
There is a need to have 'ends' that are logical success
Sub-Properties are not used in the Universal Happening
Statement should belong to the Composition Model
involved interactive part has the same name has its superset
In Figure 27, the text below the circle must be "End" instead of "Finish"
p 98 second paragraph “emdedded”
third paragraph “emdedded”
Missing notation for Interaction Role
specified fact change condition' shouldn't have a superset
Align with Classifier from Infrastructure