UAF 1.1 RTF Avatar
  1. OMG Issue

UAF11 — Multiple diagrams show inconsistencies between themselves

  • Key: UAF11-157
  • Status: closed  
  • Source: Perspecta ( Andre Kiebuzinski)
  • Summary:

    Multiple diagrams show inconsistencies between themselves, including
    a. Metadata (Figure 35) shows a link to UAFElement, but UAFElement (Figure 214) does not show link to Metadata
    b. Implements (Figure 38) shows a link to ResourceConnector, but ResourceConnector (Figure 126) does not show link to Implements
    c. CapableElement (Figure 30) shows a link to EnterprisePhase, but EnterprisePhase (Figure 42) does not show link to CapableElement
    d. ActualEnduringTask (Figure 49) shows a link to ResponsibleFor, but ResponsibleFor (Figure 113) does not show link to ActualEnduringTask
    e. ConceptRole (Figure 61) shows a link to HighLevelOperationalConcept, but HighLevelOperationalConcept (Figure 62) does not show link to ConceptRole
    f. OperationalStateDescription (Figure 84) shows a link to OperationalAgent, but OperationalAgent (Figure 64) does not show link to OperationalStateDescription
    g. ServiceSpecification (Figure 89) shows a link to ServiceInterface, but ServiceInterface (Figure 95) does not show link to ServiceSpecification
    h. ServiceMethod (Figure 90) shows a link to ServiceParameter, but ServiceParameter (Figure 91) does not show link to ServiceMethod
    i. ServiceParameter (Figure 91) shows a link to OperationalExchange, but OperationalExchange (Figure 74) does not show link to ServiceParameter
    j. Consumes (Figure 101) shows a link to OperationalActivity, but OperationalActivity (Figure 78) does not show link to Consumes
    k. Command (Figure 107) and Control (Figure 108) show a link to DataElement, but DataElement (Figure 139) does not show links to Command or Control
    l. CompetenceForRole (Figure 111) shows a link to Competence, but Competence (Figure 110) does not show link to CompetenceForRole
    m. RequiresCompetence (Figure 112) shows a link to OrganizationalResource, but OrganizationalResource (Figure 103) does not show link to RequiresCompetence
    n. ResponsibleFor (Figure 113) shows a link to ActualProject, but ActualProject (Figure 185) does not show link to ResponsibleFor
    o. ResourceRole (Figure 125) shows a link to ActualOrganizationRole, but ActualOrganizationRole (Figure 201) does not show link to ResourceRole
    p. ResourceConnector (Figure 126) shows a link to Environment, but Environment (Figure 15) does not show link to ResourceConnector
    q. VersionedElement (Figure 146) shows a link to ActualProjectMilestone, but ActualProjectMilestone (Figure 186) does not show link to VersionedElement
    r. ProtocolImplementation (Figure 150) shows a link to Protocol, but Protocol (Figure 189) does not show link to ProtocolImplementation
    s. Asset (Figure 151) shows a link to MeasurementSet, but MeasurementSet (Figure 23) does not show link to Asset
    t. SecurityProperty (Figure 156) shows a link to AssetRole, but AssetRole (Figure 170) does not show link to SecurityProperty
    u. ActualRisk (Figure 163) shows a link to ActualResponsibleResource, but ActualResponsibleResource (Figure 199) does not show link to ActualRisk
    v. OwnsRisk (Figure 172) shows a link to OrganizationalResource, but OrganizationalResource (Figure 103) does not show link to OwnsRisk
    w. Project (Figure 174) shows a link to OrganizationalResource, but OrganizationalResource (Figure 103) does not show link to Project
    x. ActualProject (Figure 184) shows a link to ActualResponsibleResource, but ActualResponsibleResource (Figure 199) does not show link to ActualProject
    y. ActualProjectMilestone (Figure 186) shows a link to ActualOrganizationalResource, but ActualOrganizationalResource (Figure 194) does not show link to ActualProjectMilestone
    z. ActualResponsibility (Figure 198) shows a link to ActualOrganizationalResource, but ActualOrganizationalResource (Figure 194) does not show link to ActualResponsibility
    aa. ActualResourceRole (Figure 202) shows a link to ResourceRole, but ResourceRole (Figure 125) does not show link to ActualResourceRole
    bb. OwnsProcess (Figure 209) shows a link to OperationalActivity, but OperationalActivity (Figure 78) does not show link to OwnsProcess

  • Reported: UAF 1.0 — Mon, 26 Mar 2018 15:06 GMT
  • Disposition: Resolved — UAF 1.1
  • Disposition Summary:

    All comments resolved

    The list of actions taken:
    UAFElement Diagram now shows link to Metadata
    Resource Connector Diagram now shows links to ResourceMessage and Implements
    Responsible For removed from Actual Enduring Task Diagram
    ConceptRole added to HighLevelOperationalConcept Diagram
    OperationalStateDescription added to OperationalAgent Diagram
    ServiceSpecification added to ServiceInterface Diagram
    ServiceParameter added to OperationalExchange Diagram
    Consumes added to OperationalActivity Diagram
    Command and Control added to DataElement diagram
    CompetenceForRole added to Competence diagram
    ResourceRole added to ActualOrganizationalRole diagram
    Resource connector added to Environment diagram
    VersionedElement added to ActualProjectMilestone Diagram
    Asset added to MeasurementSet Diagram
    ActualRisk added to ActualResponsibleResource Diagram
    ActualResourceRole added to ResourceRole Diagram

    Other issues were duplicates and were already resolved by solving other issues.

    Affected Diagrams:
    Profile
    UAFElement
    ResourceConnector
    ActualEnduringTask
    HighLevelOperationalConcept
    OperationalAgent
    ServiceInterface
    OperationalExchange
    OperationalActivity
    DataElement
    Competence
    ActualOrganizationalRole
    Environment
    ActualProjectMilestone
    MeasurementSet
    ActualResponsibleResource
    ResourceRole

  • Updated: Tue, 8 Oct 2019 17:49 GMT
  • Attachments: