SDRP — Service Typos in the Specification, UML Model, PSM, and IDL

1. The specification text and UML Model for
DeviceManagerRegistration::registerService () operation
registeringService parameter type use the ServiceComponent stereotype,
whereas the PSM and the IDL use the type Object. A more descriptive
type should be used for the PSM and the IDL.

2. DeviceManagerRegistration::registerService () operation
unregisteringService parameter type:
The specification text synopsis uses the type Service. The UML Model
uses the type ServiceComponent. The PSM and the IDL use the type
Object. These types should logically match.

3. The DeviceManagerRegistration registerDeviceManager () and
unregisterDeviceManager () operations texts refer to addition and
removal of the DeviceManager's Service(s) to/from the domain. Instead,
they should refer to ServiceComponent(s).

4. The DeviceManagerRegistration registerService () and
unregisterService () operations text refer to
registration/addition/unregistration/removal of Service(s) to/from the
domain. Instead, they should refer to ServiceComponent(s).

Proposed Solution:

1. The PSM and the IDL should use the Service typedef defined in
CFBaseTypes.idl as the registeringService/unregisteringService parameter
types for DeviceManagerRegistration::registerService
()/unregisterService ().

2. The unregisteringService parameter type for the
DeviceManagerRegistration::unregisterService () operation should be
ServiceComponent.

3. Refer to registration/unregistration of ServiceComponent(s), instead
of Service(s), in the DeviceManagerRegistration registerDeviceManager ()
and unregisterDeviceManager () operations.

4. Refer to registration/addition/unregistration/removal of
ServiceComponent(s), instead of Service(s), in the
DeviceManagerRegistration registerService () and unregisterService ()
operations.

5. The UML Model should use the ServiceComponent type instead of
SWRadioService for the registeringService/unregisteringService
parameters of the DeviceManager ServiceRegistration interface's
registerService/unregisterService operations.

Rationale: Correctness and clarity of types used, in the correct
context for the specification text, the UML Model, the PSM and the IDL.

No Data Available