-
Key: SACM-11
-
Legacy Issue Number: 16311
-
Status: closed
-
Source: MITRE ( Mr. Samuel Redwine)
-
Summary:
“Originator” is used for not only creating entity(ies), but also Approver and owner and therefore is an inappropriate class name. One possibility is “Actor”.
-
Reported: SACM 1.0b1 — Sun, 5 Jun 2011 04:00 GMT
-
Disposition: Resolved — SACM 1.0b2
-
Disposition Summary:
Change text in section 15.4, page 100 from
The Originators Class Diagram defines several elements that represent sources of
evidence. These elements are subclasses of Object element, so their formal meaning can
be further defined through a reference to a formal vocabulary or ontology developed by
the corresponding community of interest.
into
The Stakeholders Class Diagram defines several elements that represent People and
Organizations as they are involved in various statements related to evidence.
Change section 15.4.1 into the following:
15.4.1 Stakeholder (abstract)
Stakeholder is an abstract class that represents a Person or Organization as they
participate in the statements related to evidence.
Superclass
ProjectElement
Semantics
The Evidence Metamodel indirectly defines several roles in which Stakeholders are
involved in evidence statements, such as Provenance statements and Custody statements. These roles include the "source" of an evidence item or an evidence assertion, the
"supervisor" of an evidence assertion, the "owner" of an evidence item, the 'executor' of
an evidence event and the "custodian" of an evidence item. This vocabulary facilitates
exchange of structured statements related to evidence. Additional roles related to the
affiliation of a Stakeholder in some Organization can be defined by the corresponding
community of interest. These roles can be used in HasRoleIn statements and exchanged
informally, as the value of the "role" attribute". On the other hand, formal statements
related to stakeholders and their roles can be represented using the mechanism of Formal
Statements.
Change superclass of Person to 'Stakeholder'
Change superclass of Organization to 'Stakeholder'
Section 13.1.2, page 56 change "Originator" to "Stakeholder" (6 occurrences)
Section 13.1.3 page 56 change "Originator" to "Stakeholder" (6 occurrences)
Section 13.1.4 page 56-57 change "Originator" to "Stakeholder" (6 occurrences)
Section 13.4.2 page 62 change "Originator" to "Stakeholder" (4 occurrences)
Section 13.4.3 page 63 change "Originator" to "Stakeholder" (3 occurrences)
Section 13.4.4 page 64 change "Originator" to "Stakeholder" (3 occurrences)
Section 13.4.5 page 65 change "Originator" to "Stakeholder" (3 occurrences)
Section 13.4.6 page 66 change "Originator" to "Stakeholder" (3 occurrences)
Section 15.1.2 page 92 change "Originator" to "Stakeholder" (2 occurrences, change the
role name to 'stakeholder')
Section 15.1.2 page 93 change "Originator" to "Stakeholder" (1 occurrences)
Section 15.4.3 page 101 change "Originator" to "Stakeholder" (1 occurrences)
Change 'Originator' to 'Stakeholder' in section 1.5 of Annex A, page 125
Change 'Originator' to 'Stakeholder' in section 1.6 of Annex A, page 127
Rename class Originator to Stakeholder
Replace Figure 13.1 with the following: figure on page 39 of ptc/2012-06-04 rename rolename 'curator' to 'custodian' (as it is a more general term) in section 13.4.8,
page 66
Changes to Figure 13.4 (Custody Properties are described as part of the related
resolutions 16773 and 16766)
Change association of the CareOf element 13.4.8, page 66 into
custodian:Person[1]
Custodian of the evidence element
Change occurrences of the text 'curator' to 'custodian' page 14
Change occurrences of the text 'curator' to 'custodian' in section 13.4.2 IsAcquiredAt
Change occurrences of the text 'curator' to 'custodian' in section 13.4.3 IsCreatedAt
Change occurrences of the text 'curator' to 'custodian' in section 13.4.4 IsTransferredTo
Change occurrences of the text 'curator' to 'custodian' in section 13.4.5 IsRevokedAt
Change occurrences of the text 'curator' to 'custodian' in section 13.4.6 IsGeneratedAt
Change occurrences of the text 'curator' to 'custodian' in section 13.4.7 CareOf
Replace Figure 15.1 and Figure 15.4 (described in the resolutions 16815 and 16816)
Replace the text 'source' to 'stakeholder' in table on page 15. -
Updated: Fri, 6 Mar 2015 20:58 GMT
SACM — Change name of “Originator”
- Key: SACM-11
- OMG Task Force: Structured Assurance Case Metamodel (SACM) FTF