-
Key: I2JAV13-11
-
Status: open
-
Source: Airbus Group ( Mr. Oliver M. Kellogg)
-
Summary:
This is intended for the Joint Initial submission to the IDL4 to Java Language Mapping RFP,
mars/18-08-01.
However, on filling in the OMG issue reporting form, I could not find a way to specify this; as a fallback, I reference the IDL to Java Mapping 1.3 (formal/08-01-11) to which the same issue also applies.Many of the IDL to Java translators support an option to specify a Java package prefix for the generated code (e.g. Oracle idlj option -pkgPrefix; JacORB option -i2jpackage; rtiddsgen option -package).
This is not exactly equivalent to hard coding the prefix as modules in the IDL: When using the translator option, other language mappings do not see the prefix.The package prefix provided to the IDL translator may produce a conflict with names in the IDL file.
Example:// file: test.idl module test { enum com_t { zero, one }; struct org_t { short foo; }; typedef string<16> net_t; struct structure { com_t com; // "com" is in conflict when providing prefix option such as: com.acme org_t org; // "org" is in conflict when providing prefix option such as: org.acme net_t net; // "net" is in conflict when providing prefix option such as: net.acme }; };
Notice that the Java generated for this IDL does not compile but it does compile for other languages (C++, Ada, etc).
Section 4.2 (Names) contains:
In general IDL names and identifiers are mapped to Java names and identifiers with no change.
If a name collision could be generated in the mapped Java code, the name collision is resolved by
prepending an underscore (_) to the mapped name.Section 7.1.1 of mars/18-08-01 contains similar text.
I suggest adding a further sentence:
This also applies to name collisions caused by a Java package prefix specified at the IDL to Java translator.
-
Reported: I2JAV 1.3 — Wed, 3 Oct 2018 09:07 GMT
-
Updated: Tue, 16 Oct 2018 19:37 GMT
I2JAV13 — Package prefix specified at the IDL to Java translator
- Key: I2JAV13-11
- OMG Task Force: IDL to Java 2004 RTF