DDS11 — Unspecified behavior of DataReader/DataWriter creation w/t mismatched Topic

The specification does not currently state whether it is permissible to create a DataReader or DataWriter with a TopicDescription that was created from a DomainParticipant other than that used to create the reader or writer's factory.

Proposed Resolution:
The use case in question is not allowed; create_datareader and create_datawriter should return nil in that case.

Proposed Revised Text:
The following paragraph should be appended to section 2.1.2.4.1.5 create_datawriter:
The Topic passed to this operation must have been created from the same DomainParticipant that was used to create this Publisher. If the Topic was created from a different DomainParticipant, this operation will fail and return a nil result.
The following paragraph should be appended to section 2.1.2.5.2.5 create_datareader:
The TopicDescription passed to this operation must have been created from the same DomainParticipant that was used to create this Subscriber. If the TopicDescription was created from a different DomainParticipant, this operation will fail and return a nil result.

No Data Available