CMMN 1.1 RTF Avatar
  1. OMG Issue

CR — Inconsistencies between class diagram figures and attribute tables

  • Key: CR-1
  • Legacy Issue Number: 19440
  • Status: closed  
  • Source: International Business Machines ( Mr. Mike Marin)
  • Summary:

    Multiple inconsistencies between class diagram figures and attribute tables, as follows:

    a) Inconsistence between Figure 5.1 (page 9), figure 5.3 (page 15) and table 5.4 (page 11). Note that CaseFileItemDefinition has “name” in the figures, but name does not appear in the table. It has name in the xsd.

    b) Inconsistence between Figure 5.1 (page 9), figure 5.3 (page 15) and table 5.3 (page 11). Note that Import has “name” in the figure, but name does not appear in the table. Does not have name in xsd.

    c) Inconsistence between Figure 5.1 (page 9), Figure 5.10 (page 34) and table 5.33 (page 38). Note that Process has “name” in the figure, but name does not appear in the table. It has name in the xsd.

    d) Inconsistence between Figure 5.2 (page 13), Figure 5.6 (page 21) and table 5.26 (page 29). Note that Stage in the figures is missing autoComplete.

    e) Inconsistence between Figure 5.4 (page 17) and table 5.31 (page 34). Note that Task in the figure is missing isBlocking.

    f) Inconsistence between Figure 5.5 (page 19) and table 5.9 (page 14). Note that Role is missing “name” in the figure.

    g) Figure 5.7 (page 24) has two copies of CaseFileItem, and they have different attributes.

    h) Inconsistence between Figure 5.9 (page 30) and table 5.11 (page 16). Note that CaseFileItem is missing “name” and “multiplicity” in the figure.

    i) Figure 5.10 (page 34) has two copies of Expression, and they have different attributes.

    j) Inconsistence between Figure 5.11 (page 40), Figure 5.9 (page 30) and table 5.29 (page 32). Note that DiscretionaryItem has “name” in figure 5.11, but name does not appear in the table, or in figure 5.9. Does not have name in xsd.

    k) Section 5.4.11 PlanItemControl, page 40, instead of having a table for PlanItemControl, it was labeled “Figure 5.12”, which is wrong. It should be a table.

  • Reported: CMMN 1.0 — Sun, 1 Jun 2014 04:00 GMT
  • Disposition: Resolved — CMMN 1.1
  • Disposition Summary:

    *Fix inconsistencies in UML model diagrams and attribute tables in spec *

    Fix the issues reported in the tables and diagrams.
    The issue reported on DiscretionaryItem is handled separately as part of issue
    CR-37

  • Updated: Tue, 29 Mar 2016 15:06 GMT
  • Attachments: