-
Key: COMMONS-3
-
Status: closed
-
Source: Thematix Partners LLC ( Mrs. Elisa F. Kendall)
-
Summary:
(1) Different fonts: I can understand why you are using a fixed-width font in the metadata tables to identify the right-hand columns as the actual values of the terms listed in the left column.
In the Properties tables I suggest to use a sans-serif font (e.g. Ariel) for the Axioms column to clearly distinguish the Axioms from the Annotations
(2) The Properties tables are too cramped. It is not clear what the purpose of the name repetitions in parentheses in the Name column is. However, these repetitions take up unnecessarily much horizontal space. This could be solved by always moving them in a line under the bold camel-case name. The recovered horizontal space should be then allocated to the Axioms column, which is way too narrow. Many axioms are mutilated by inappropriate line breaks.
(3) Since you are not using vertical separators (which is ok), you should extend the gutter whitespace between columns to improve readability, in particular between Annotation and Axiom columns.
(4) Clause 6 should contain good explanations regarding the fonts and the table layouts [and the parenthesis names]. -
Reported: Commons 1.0a1 — Fri, 1 Jul 2022 18:45 GMT
-
Disposition: Closed; No Change — COMMONS 1.0
-
Disposition Summary:
Most formatting issues raised in AB review were addressed via errata
We added gutter space and separators to make the tables easier to read in a revision via errata prior to AB approval and final voting at the June meeting. Moving labels (which are the human-readable rather than camel case names) to the middle column is something that we can do once we agree on a format for ontology generation in LaTeX in a future version of this specification. The format we used for the Commons is the same as recent FIBO, LCC, and other ontology specifications until such time as we are able to automate generation of the material.
-
Updated: Tue, 28 Mar 2023 17:31 GMT
COMMONS — The format of the tables throughout the specification needs improvement
- Key: COMMONS-3
- OMG Task Force: Commons Ontology Library (Commons) 1.0 FTF