BPMN 2.0 FTF Avatar
  1. OMG Issue

BPMN2 — The case of some attribute name is not consistent.

  • Key: BPMN2-3
  • Legacy Issue Number: 14244
  • Status: closed  
  • Source: Trisotech ( Mr. Denis Gagne)
  • Summary:

    Reported by dga...@trisotech.com, Jun 08, 2009

    It seems that lower case is the standard, but some attributes like
    ReceiveTask.Instanciate, UserTask.Imlementation for example, but there are
    other attributes as well.

    The same comment applies to type name string vs String, Boolean vs
    Boolean, etcÂ…

    Comment 1 by hudoneric, Jun 09, 2009

    The case of the gatewayDirection on p.111 is lower case. The values of other
    enumerations in the document are capitalized.

    Comment 2 by hudoneric, Jun 10, 2009

    Same thing for multi-instance behavior on p.203.

    Comment 3 by hudoneric, Jun 10, 2009

    The case of the enumeration UserTaskImplementation is not the same in the
    specification (p. 179) and the schema (p. 181).

    Comment 4 by hudoneric, Jun 10, 2009

    The case of the methodon p.192is lower case. The values of other
    enumerations in the document are capitalized.

  • Reported: BPMN 2.0b1 — Wed, 2 Sep 2009 04:00 GMT
  • Disposition: Resolved — BPMN 2.0
  • Disposition Summary:

    (a) Table 10.10, page 140 (170 pdf), second row, first column: Change "Instantiate:" to "instantiate:"
    (b) Table 10.13, page 146 (176 pdf), first row, first column: Change "Implementation:" to "implementation:"
    (c) Table 10.2, page 135 (165 pdf), first row, first column: Change "String:" to "string:"
    (d) Table 8.47, page 80 (110 pdf), first row, first column: Change "unspecified | converging | diverging |mixed" to "Unspecified | Converging | Diverging |Mixed"
    (e) Table 8.47, page 80 (110 pdf), first row, second column: Change "unspecified" to "Unspecified", "converging" to "Converging ", "diverging" to "Diverging", and
    "mixed" to "Mixed"
    (f) Figure 8.25, page 79 (109 pdf): Capitalize the items within the GatewayDirection enumeration.
    (g) Table 10.26, page 172 (202 pdf), second row on page, first column: Change "none | one | all | complex" to "None | One | All | Complex"
    (h) Table 10.26, page 172 (202 pdf), second row on page, second column: Change "none" to "None", "one" to "One", "all" to "All ", and "complex" to "Complex"
    Table 10.13, page 146 (176 pdf), first row, first column: Change all types of UserTaskImplementation from uppercase to lowercase
    Note that some of the changes to the case of key words such as string, boolean, and integer or the case of enumeration values were not documented.
    Disposition: Resolved
    Voting Record: 22 Yes, 0 No, 3 Abstain (Votes)
    OMG Issue No: 14246
    Title: Page 227 Table 10-56 the attributes optionalOutput and whileExecutingOuput are wrongly typed DataInput
    Source: Trisotech (Denis Gagne dgagne@trisotech.com)
    Severity: Significant
    Summary: (

  • Updated: Fri, 6 Mar 2015 20:57 GMT