We want to report the following small changes to the Beta 1 spec: Page 13 corrected font of section “Normative References” Page 13 updated CORBA v3.0.3 to v3.1 in section 1.1 and 3 Page 18 7.4.1 corrected mechamism to mechanism Page 12 7.12 changed typechecking into “type checking” Page:22 7.11 Mapping for Wide string types: change first phrase to "The OMG IDL Wide string type" 7.12.2 Change last sentence 'if the Any contained a specific' should be 'if the Any contains a specific' Page:27 7.20 para 4: change "a accessor" to "an accessor" 7.20 updated reference to CORBA v3.1 Page 29 Removed a few empty lines 7.23 : 'get ‘firstname, as defined' should be '_get_firstname, as defined' Page 31 7.25.1 Changed toplevel to “top level” Page 31 Removed reference to Test.idl and TestS.rb, that only makes the example unclear Page 32 Changed accomodate to accommodate Page 34 7.25.2, changed “Ofcourse” to “Of course” and “coulde” to “could” Change 'The implementation method result depends then on the number of result values:' to 'The implementation method result depends on the number of result values as follows:' Check heading of table 7.3

Agreed to make the following revisions to the document

In the default implementation in section 7.25.2, class "PortableServer::DynamicImplementation", there is an "&&" which should be "&&".

Replace & with &

Review comment from the AB, can address this in the next RTF

Specific Comments:

Section 7.19.4 : minor grammar error - change 'mapped on' to 'mapped to' or mapped 'on to' if that is what you mean.

In section 7.19.4 change the part of the first sentence from:
An IDL abstract valuetype is mapped on a Ruby module
To:
An IDL abstract valuetype is mapped to a Ruby module

The spec lacks the mapping of valuetypes, this should be added

Add the revised text as below to the specification

Abstract interface spec is missing. Should be added.

Add the text as below to the specification