| Key | Issue | Reported | Fixed | Disposition | Status | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CPP1117-28 | Add && setter | CPP11 1.6b1 | open | |||
| CPP1117-27 | std::optional should be passed as const& | CPP11 1.6b1 | open | |||
| CPP1117-26 | Formatting c++/idl in text | CPP11 1.6b1 | open | |||
| CPP1117-24 | Fix bitset mapping | CPP11 1.6b1 | open | |||
| CPP1116-38 | Improve wording | CPP11 1.6b1 | open |
For the optional mapping example a `void age(IDL::optional<float>&&)` is lacking, like described for some types in chapter 6.14
For the example code, for the setter, the std::optional should be passed as const&, see https://stackoverflow.com/questions/69277649/does-passing-an-stdoptionalt-by-reference-actually-save-copying
Within the text of chapter 6.31/6.32 (IDL4) all C++/IDL should use a different font to make it clear it is code, just as in the other chapters.
For anyone using the class mapping of a structure the spec should also provide a class mapping for a bitset, that way they have a consistent API. Also why is a inherited bitset not mapped to C++ inheritance, by removing the inheritance the inheritance relation can't be used in C++ also
The spec has the following sentence:
The _d discriminator modifier can only be used to set the discriminant to a value within the same union member.
This is not really clear and should be improved, maybe
The _d discriminator modifier can only be used to set the discriminant to a value that has the same union member as currently selected.