SBVR 1.1 RTF Avatar
  1. OMG Issue

SBVR11 — Move the Definitions in Subclause 8.5 to Clause 13

  • Key: SBVR11-98
  • Legacy Issue Number: 14844
  • Status: closed  
  • Source: Rule ML Initiative ( John Hall)
  • Summary:

    Subclause 8.5 is about the interchange files defined in Clause 15.
    The syntax for these files is (mostly) defined in Clause 13; the content of Subclause 8.5 should be placed in Clause 13.

  • Reported: SBVR 1.0 — Wed, 9 Dec 2009 05:00 GMT
  • Disposition: Resolved — SBVR 1.1
  • Disposition Summary:

    From Issue 13138 (as of 5 Dec 2008):
    "Subclause 8.5 includes concepts conceptual schema and fact model that have no bearing on the content of the SBVR metamodel (as defined in the Clause 15.1 XMI file) or an SBVR model (to be illustrated by Clause 15.3 SBVR model of SBVR file). Rather they explain the structure of the SBVR model file in Clause 15.3 as an XML file containing a fact model population for an externally referenced SBVR XSD conceptual schema."

    The conceptual schema for interchange is the XSD, the facts are the XML content of the interchange file.

    Supporting arguments for making the change:
    • The specification does not place the syntax of Clauses 8, 9, 11 and 12 in Clause 8 - it is in Annex C
    • The specification does not place (most of) the syntax of Clause 15 in Clause 8 - it is in Clause 13
    Some corrections are needed:
    • 'fact model' has two parts: 'conceptual schema' and 'fact population'
    • 'fact model is based on conceptual schema" should be 'fact population is based on conceptual schema'
    • 'conceptual schema includes fact' should be 'fact population includes fact'

    Dependencies with other Issue Resolutions
    Issue 13138: Move Fact Model Container Concepts from Clause 8 to Clause 10
    This issue removes the definitions in Subclause 8.5 from the scope of Issue 13138.
    Resolution:
    Move the content of Subclause 8.5 into Clause 13, with the corrections listed in Discussion, above.

    Resolution:
    Resolved by the resolution of Issue 13838
    Revised Text:
    None
    Disposition: Closed, no change required

  • Updated: Fri, 6 Mar 2015 20:58 GMT