DMN 1.4 RTF Avatar
  1. OMG Issue

DMN14 — Inconsistency DMNv1.2 dropping [a]=a and get entries example

  • Key: DMN14-65
  • Status: closed  
  • Source: Red Hat ( Matteo Mortari)
  • Summary:

    Since DMNv1.2 the spec dropped the equivalence of:

    [a] = a
    

    because it does not apply to the statement that

    a singleton list L, when used in an expression where a list is not expected, behaves as if L[1] is written.

    So the expression

    [a] = a
    

    on DMNv1.2 is expected to return false.

    However, in section 10.3.2.6 Context of the spec, it provides the following statement for the get entries function:

    To retrieve a list of key,value pairs from a context m, the following built-in function may be used: get entries(m).
    For example, the following is true:

    get entries({key 1 : "value 1 "})[key="key 1 "].value = "value 1 "
    

    BUT

    get entries({key1 : "value1"})[key="key1"].value = "value1"
    
      by substitution:
    
    [ { key : "key1", value : "value1" } ][key="key1"].value = "value1"
    [ { key : "key1", value : "value1" } ].value = "value1"
    [ "value1" ] = "value1"
    

    according to DMNv1.2 should be false

    By the same principle that the DMNv1.2 for the following literal expression:

    [123] = 123
    

    on DMNv1.2 is expected to be false

  • Reported: DMN 1.2b1 — Wed, 30 Jan 2019 14:43 GMT
  • Disposition: Deferred — DMN 1.4
  • Disposition Summary:

    Defer to DMN 1.5

    Defer to DMN 1.5

  • Updated: Thu, 31 Mar 2022 19:30 GMT