- 
                            Key: CORBA3-11
- 
                            Legacy Issue Number: 3599
- 
                            Status: closed
- 
                            Source: Floorboard Software ( Jonathan Biggar)
- 
                            Summary:I set out reading ptc/2000-04-05 to answer a question: how could a 
 client interceptor for the OTS implement the proper behavior for the DII
 get_response or get_next_response operations that require the
 WrongTransaction to be raised if the current thread is not properly
 associated with the same transaction as the request.I wasn't able to answer this question authoritatively, because there is 
 nothing in the Portable Interceptors Chapter that indicates the proper
 time sequencing of when the client side request interceptor operations
 are invoked in relation to the use of the DII (or the AMI_ messaging
 interfaces either.)By inference, it appears to me that the only way to allow an OTS client {reply,exception,other}
 request interceptor to exhibit the proper semantics is for the ORB to
 not make calls to receive_when the response is 
 received from the protocol stack, but instead to make them when
 get_response or get_next_response is called by the application.This paragraph in 21.3.7.2: "Asynchronous requests are simply two separate requests. The first 
 request receives no reply. The second receives a normal reply. So the
 normal (no exceptions) flow is: first request - send_request followed by
 receive_other; second request - send_request followed by receive_reply."is also not particularly useful, since it doesn't give any indication 
 how the interceptor can distinguish the "first request" from the "second
 request".So, to sum up, the PI chapter needs explicit information showing the 
 time sequencing of when the request interceptor operations are invoked
 in relationship to a static call, a DII call, and AMI_ calls.
- 
                            Reported: CPP 1.1 — Tue, 9 May 2000 04:00 GMT
- 
                            Disposition: Resolved — CORBA 3.0.2
- 
                            Disposition Summary:see above 
- 
                            Updated: Fri, 6 Mar 2015 20:58 GMT
CORBA3 — Detail lacking in when request interceptors are called
- Key: CORBA3-11
- OMG Task Force: Core 2002 RTF